[She'd probably scoff if that wasn't such a rare look on him.]

...Seriously? [How could he not know? Even in her memory, she was sure of it. The only complication was they didn't know Kirei's whereabouts to properly question him. Unless—No, that's not possible either.] I'm sure Caster's only made the church her base recently, since I spoke with you on the phone after that incident at school. Did Shinji never go to you in the first place?

[He's a coward, so she'd find that twice as shocking over him suddenly having the most powerful Servant in the war.]